The usual health checks on the U.S. economy have been disabled during the government shutdown, leaving analysts to comb over private data for clues. What theyโre seeing, at least according to Moodyโs, isnโt great.
Markets are climbing confidently despite the fact that last week concluded without the usual jobs data. Releases by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) are often key insights into the future trajectory of the economy, but investors are taking the optimistic view in the absence of any bad news.
But Moodyโs is warning that private reporting paints a less rosy picture, describing role additions to the jobs market as โpaltry.โ Everyone from Wall Street to the Federal Reserve knows Americaโs labor market is weakening โ adding just 22,000 jobs according to the BLSโs latest release for August โ but are unsure by how much.
Moodyโs chief economist Mark Zandi wrote in a note over the weekend that data from Revelio Labs, which scrapes info from professional networking sites like LinkedIn to estimate jobs growth, shows that employment increased by some 60,000 roles in September. This, he added, was โalmost entirely in the education and health care sector.โ
The positions arenโt just exclusive to certain sectors, he added, but regions: โAlso of note, the job growth last month was almost exclusively in California, New York, and Massachusettsโ โ three of the top five states in terms of GDP per capita.
Zandi also referenced data from payroll giant ADP, which found private jobs fell 32,000 last month. While Zandi said Revelio overestimates the good news, he said ADP understates the bad โas government employment surely also fell in the month given the ongoing DOGE-related cuts. ADPโs data are based on the payroll records it processes for many companies.โ
He continued: โThe bulk of the job gains in the ADP numbers were also in health care, and only very large companies, with over 500 employees, added to payrolls. Smaller companies are getting hit hardest by the tariffs and restrictive immigration policies.
โAveraging the Revelio and ADP employment estimates for September suggests that there was essentially no job growth during the month,โ the economist concluded, also referencing the Conference Boardโs recent reporting that consumers are finding it increasingly difficult to find positions.ย
This data showed confidence hasnโt been so low since the end of the pandemic, and added that โthereโs no better predictor of changes in unemployment, which thus likely rose again in September.โ
Data from jobs site Glassdoor is a similarly mixed picture. Chief economist Daniel Zhao shared on Friday that while confidence was marginally up last month, it was still down compared to a year ago.ย
So too is pay: Salaries declined slightly in September, averaging $71,831 per year on Glassdoor, down 0.4% from August ($72,128). On a year-over-year basis, salaries grew 4.9% in September, a deceleration from 5.4% in August, and the slowest annual pace of growth since April 2025.
Zandi continued: โThe bottom line is that not having the BLS jobs data is a serious problem for assessing the health of the economy and making good policy decisions. But the private sources of jobs data are admirably filling the information gap, at least for now. And this data shows that the job market is weak and getting weaker.โ
Fed through a keyhole
As the impasse in Washington shows no sign of easing, the majority of economists are now expecting the government shutdown to continue past the middle of October โ the next meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) to decide the base rate.
Without the data being shared by government agencies during the blackout, UBSโs Paul Donovan previously warned โprivate data is like viewing the economy through a keyhole โ clear, but with a narrow field of vision. Official data is like opening the door. Private data relies on official data to model the bits of the economy outside its field of vision, and that modeling becomes less accurate in the absence of official data.โ
Likewise, Pantheon Macroeconomicsโ senior U.S. economist Oliver Allen warned clients in a note last week that while data from the likes of ADP will hold more weight in a void of information from the BLS, official data may come back more depressed than expected.ย
Allen wrote: โWe suspect the BLS estimates for growth in private payrolls in September โ when eventually released โ will be flattered by a big jump in leisure and hospitality jobs, the likely result of poor seasonal adjustment. Our forecast, therefore, remains for a 75K gain in private payrolls, although we see headline payrolls rising by just 50K, partly due to a further drop in federal government employment.โ
Written by Eleanor Pringle for Fortune as โAmerica saw โessentially no job growthโ last month, warns Moodyโs, and any roles added were in three wealthy statesโ and republished with permission.
