When millions of people were forced to work remotely during the pandemic, concerns about loneliness and social isolation were perhaps inevitable. In the years that followed, concerns about loneliness strengthened the case for returning employees to the office, as advocates argued that greater face-to-face interaction could help employees feel less isolated.
But is remote work solely to blame, and is returning to the office the solution?
New research suggests the answer is more complicated than many employers might assume. A study of U.K. workers found that, during the pandemic, people in occupations suited to remote work experienced a relative increase in loneliness and adverse mental health symptoms compared with those in jobs that required on-site attendance. Yet by 2023, these differences had disappeared, although remote work remained part of working life.
This raises an important question: Was remote work itself responsible for the rise in loneliness, or was it one of several forces that isolated people during the pandemic? If it was only one contributor, a mandatory return to the office may not fix the problem. After all, mere proximity to colleagues does not necessarily mean that people feel connected to one another.
The Research Challenging Assumptions About Remote Work and Loneliness
A paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), Loneliness, Mental Health and the Work-From-Home Revolution, challenges the assumption that remote work has contributed to lasting increases in loneliness and poorer mental health. The study examines whether the significant increase in working from home following the pandemic was accompanied by changes in workers’ reported loneliness and mental health.
The researchers compared two groups of U.K. workers: those employed in occupations that could be performed remotely before the pandemic and those whose jobs generally required them to be physically present at a workplace. They then examined how working arrangements and wellbeing outcomes changed over time.
Although people in remote-compatible roles continued to work from home at much higher rates than before the pandemic, the differences in loneliness and poorer mental health between these workers and those in occupations less suited to remote work had disappeared by 2023. In other words, remote work prevailed, but the differences in wellbeing outcomes between the two groups did not persist.
The research does not claim that remote work was not linked to loneliness or mental health during the pandemic. It found that the differences were small and temporary. The fact that these gaps had closed by 2023 also does not mean that no one experienced isolation as a result of working remotely.
Loneliness was already a widespread problem before remote work took off. Roughly 39% of workers in the study reported feeling lonely before the pandemic. After the pandemic began, workers in remote-compatible jobs saw their loneliness rise by less than two percentage points more than those in on-site roles. That small gap suggests remote work may not be the main cause of loneliness.
Speaking to Allwork.Space, Dr. Spearing explained that the findings were not what the researchers had initially anticipated: “When we began working on this paper, we expected to find evidence of significant changes in mental health and loneliness for people in those occupations where there is a greater opportunity to work from home.”
He explained that there were good reasons to expect remote work to have had both significant positive and negative effects on loneliness and mental health. However, the researchers were surprised by what emerged when they identified who was more or less affected.
“Although people in certain occupations significantly increase their use of remote work, there is very little long-run change in measured loneliness or mental health symptoms.”
Why the Findings Need to Be Viewed in a Wider Context
The research helps us understand the relationship between remote working and loneliness, but it leaves some questions unanswered. For example, although the differences in wellbeing between remote and on-site workers had disappeared by 2023, the study could not explain why.
When asked what might explain this phenomenon, Dr. Spearing outlined three possible explanations:
- Employers increasingly moved away from fully remote arrangements towards hybrid working from around 2022 onwards. This may have had less impact on employees than working entirely remotely.
- People may have adapted to changing working conditions over time, learning how to integrate remote work into their lives in a healthier way.
- Employees who experimented with remote work but found it unsuitable eventually returned to on-site work.
Dr. Spearing emphasized that, because of data limitations, the researchers could not establish which, if any, of these explanations accounted for the findings.
There is also the question of how much the wider circumstances of the pandemic contributed to the loneliness and poorer mental health observed during this period. The sudden shift to working from home coincided with lockdowns, restrictions on socialising, fewer opportunities for social interaction and considerable uncertainty. In other words, people were not only adjusting to a different way of working but also experiencing an unprecedented disruption to their social and personal lives. As a result, it is difficult to know how much of the loneliness experienced during this period was due to remote working and how much was linked to the wider disruption caused by the pandemic.
The researchers also explored whether certain groups were more susceptible to the effects of remote working, examining characteristics such as marital status, parenthood and personality. They found some modest differences; for example, married people and parents, particularly men, were slightly more likely to report feeling lonely. Dr. Spearing cautioned, however, that these differences were relatively small and might partly reflect pre-pandemic levels of loneliness rather than an increase attributable to remote working.
“They still experience a small effect, and this effect may simply be driven by the fact that they started off with lower feelings of loneliness at the start of the study. Overall, we did not find that there was any particular group who experienced large adverse effects from the remote work revolution in the long term.”
Another consideration is that people in remote-friendly occupations are not necessarily comparable with those whose roles require them to work on site. They are more likely to have a university degree, work in professional or managerial positions, earn higher salaries, and have longer commutes. These differences matter because individual working conditions, financial circumstances, and personal lives can all affect people’s experience of remote working. What works well for one employee may not work as well for another, making it difficult to draw sweeping conclusions about the impact of remote work across the workforce.
What Can Employers Take Away from the Research?
The findings raise another important question for employers: if the increase in remote work has not led to lasting increases in loneliness or poorer mental health, is restricting it really the best way to support employee wellbeing?
Dr. Spearing was keen to clarify the intended scope of the study: “Our research is intended to investigate population-level trends, rather than implications for employers.”
He explained that the findings suggest the surge in remote work experienced during and after the Covid-19 pandemic is unlikely to have had persistent adverse effects on mental health:
“For employers as a whole, this result suggests that a blanket restriction on remote work would not be beneficial for their employees’ wellbeing.”
However, this should not be interpreted as evidence that remote working is always beneficial or that it never contributes to loneliness. Population-level findings do not apply to every employee, occupation, or workplace. Some people may thrive working remotely, while others may find that reduced face-to-face contact affects their sense of connection, motivation or belonging. For employers, this offers a different perspective on the ongoing debate about where employees should work.
“Our research does not imply that remote work can never be harmful for some workers, sometimes,” Dr. Spearing said.
Dr. Spearing also highlighted that research into the relationship between remote working and wellbeing is still developing: “As a research field, economists are only beginning to understand the nuances of the benefits and costs of remote work,” he states. “These benefits and costs are likely to differ markedly across occupations and industries as much as they are across individual workers.”
For employers, this suggests that a one-size-fits-all approach to workplace attendance may overlook different employee needs.
Ultimately, employers need to look beyond where people work and focus more closely on what helps them feel socially connected. Blaming remote work alone for a wider loneliness problem risks overlooking the many other influences on people’s social lives. Equally, this does not mean dismissing the importance of workplace relationships or the opportunities for connection that spending time together can provide. Broader changes in society, including declining opportunities for face-to-face interaction, also need to be part of the conversation.
Remote work offers genuine benefits, from greater autonomy and flexibility to reduced commuting time. The challenge for employers is to retain these advantages while ensuring employees still have opportunities to develop meaningful relationships and feel that they belong in the workplace.














