Dr. Gleb Tsipursky – The Office Whisperer
Nirit Cohen – WorkFutures
Angela Howard – Culture Expert
Drew Jones – Design & Innovation
Jonathan Price – CRE & Flex Expert
- DEI programs face criticism, spurring some companies to focus on DOI, which emphasizes opportunity and inclusion.
- The Trump administration’s actions on DEI led companies to rethink diversity strategies and priorities.
- JPMorgan Chase highlights DOI, focusing on career growth and equal opportunities for all employees.
Companies used to invest significant resources in diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs to create more diverse and welcoming work environments.
These initiatives have helped organizations improve hiring practices, workplace culture, and representation across various demographic groups.
Now, with pushback against DEI, a new concept is starting to take hold: diversity, opportunity, and inclusion (DOI).
DEI Under Scrutiny: The Trump Administration’s Impact
Corporate DEI programs have faced some serious pushback, particularly under the Trump administration, which sought to reduce or eliminate these policies. The administration made efforts to ban DEI training in federal agencies, arguing that such programs were divisive and counterproductive. These moves led to an ongoing debate about whether DEI programs were truly effective or if they only fueled division.
Under the Trump administration, the federal government moved to eliminate or limit DEI training and policies in federal agencies. Executive orders were passed that sought to restrict DEI initiatives, particularly those involving “unconscious bias” training, and these measures were widely criticized for stifling efforts to address racial and gender inequality in the workplace.
The administration argued that DEI policies would contribute to discrimination rather than helping to eliminate it.
While the Trump administration’s actions were largely focused on federal agencies, the effects rippled through private companies as well. Many business leaders began to question the effectiveness of traditional DEI policies and whether they could be an obstacle to addressing broader issues like merit, talent development, and innovation.
In response, many companies have been rethinking their DEI policies, questioning whether traditional diversity efforts focus too heavily on demographics. As DEI programs face criticism and scrutiny, the call for DOI is growing.
A notable example of this shift is JPMorgan Chase, which has begun placing more focus on DOI, emphasizing the importance of providing employees from all backgrounds with the opportunities and resources needed to succeed.
What Is DOI and How Does It Differ from DEI?
While DEI programs typically focus on demographic representation, diversity, opportunity, and inclusion supposedly adds an additional layer to the conversation. DOI not only aims to create diverse teams but also ensures that every individual within the organization has equal access to opportunities for professional growth.
For companies like JPMorgan Chase, the goal of DOI is to hire a diverse team and to provide those employees with equal chances for career development and leadership roles. DOI intends to help companies create a work culture where all employees, regardless of their background, are provided with the resources and support needed to thrive in their roles.
What’s Wrong with the “E” in DEI?
As part of the DEI scrutiny, questions emerged about whether focusing too much on “equity” might actually hinder progress. Critics argue that when companies emphasize equity, they risk overlooking merit, talent development, and individual achievement, potentially leading to a sense of favoritism or forced inclusivity.
This has led to a new focus on diversity, opportunity, and inclusion (DOI), where the emphasis is not just on representation, but on giving everyone, regardless of their background, the opportunity to succeed and grow within the organization.
Will Other Companies Follow JPMorgan’s Example?
As more companies witness the impact of the Trump administration’s push to reduce DEI programs, many are reassessing their approach to diversity.
JPMorgan Chase’s commitment to DOI could inspire other companies to rethink their diversity strategies and adopt similar approaches, rather than entirely doing away with DEI initiatives altogether.
